Home > Fine Gael > Can Enda Kenny continue as leader?

Can Enda Kenny continue as leader?

Does Fine Gael need a change in leadership to hope to lead the next government? No, but it might still be a good idea.

Whether or not Richard Bruton decides to challenge Enda Kenny’s leadership of the party at the parliamentary party, Fine Gael has the policies at hand to convince people that we should lead government. We will win based on policies, such as NewEra, which should be sold for what it is, a plan to improve our competitiveness by introducing a business orientation to the provision of services like broadband, water and energy, or NewPolitics, which will reduce the scale of our government institutions while increasing accountability and accessibility. We should convince people on the basis of the positions we have taken over the years, whether in opposing elements of social partnership like benchmarking, or in the past two years, taking a case-by-case rather than a populist approach to government actions. Here Fine Gael should be seen favourably against Labour. Fine Gael supported the guarantee of bank deposits, but while opposing that bailout of bondholders. Fine Gael supported the Croke Park deal with the trade union leaders, something Eamon Gilmore and the Labour Party couldn’t take a stand on until Jack O’Connor had given the word that it had SIPTU support.

As I have written before, Enda Kenny has been a very good leader in electoral terms. At the 2002 general, when the party fell to 31 seats, some commentators spoke of a continual demise in the party’s fortunes. Within two years of Kenny’s leadership, the party had bested Fianna Fáil for the first time, beating them at the European elections in 2004. He led the party to 51 seats in 2007 and then Fine Gael became the largest party at a local level in 2009. This is an incredible record for his eight years of leadership to date.

But even after all that, Enda Kenny might not be the best man to lead the party into the next election. We are facing a contest primarily between Fine Gael and Labour, and Labour have gained ground. Even if we can win some of this back, to find ourselves ahead of Labour again, the ratio in seats between the two parties after the next election will be crucial. In ways, by their commitment to many of the elements of social partnership through their trade union links, Labour is simply proposing more of the same. It is important for the country that Fine Gael has a very clear advantage over Labour.

It is unfortunate to say it, but despite his good work internally, in bringing many good candidates into the party and forward to electoral success, Enda Kenny is not popular nationally, and particularly in Dublin. He is not disliked, many simply do not see him as an alternative Taoiseach. We have to be realistic and wonder how much of the fortune the party has had in the polls was due to our own people and policies, and how much was because we were seen as the most likely alternative to Fianna Fáil.

This is not just about Friday’s Irish Times/MRBI poll, or the last Sunday Times/Red C poll, which showed the party stagnating in support. There have been internal mutterings about Kenny’s leadership for a while, reflecting large sections of the general public. These rose to prominence after the resignation of George Lee, but no one in the parliamentary party wanted to give him credit for deciding the fate of the party leader.

RBrutonI do believe the party would be stronger nationally led by Richard Bruton, provided the parliamentary party gets behind him fully were he to succeed Enda Kenny. He does command confidence and respect, of a sort which the Irish people now desire. This should not be seen as a sign of internal division and rancour, as the party has successfully avoided since 2002, but rather as our best strategic decision when facing one of the most important elections for the country in recent decades. In all likelihood that before the next election, there will be a three-way leadership debate. Richard Bruton would be seen as a fresh face, and his command of economics would be reassuring in that event. The parliamentary party have to face this action head on, and not let it linger. Even if Enda Kenny were to come out of this continuing as leader, it would put the matter publicly behind the party.

One way or other, this needs to be resolved this week, resolved decisively and put to rest. And most importantly, we can’t let this lead to continuing divisions in the front bench into different camps after this week.

  1. 14 June, 2010 at 1:29 pm

    Very interesting times indeed for Fine Gael. What do you make of Labour’s upsurge in popularity? A new trend or a mere blip?

    • William
      14 June, 2010 at 2:49 pm

      I think it’s too early to know really about Labour. We could be witnessing a real change in Irish political structure. A stronger social democratic party than the Labour Party here would be normal in other European countries, and in large part it was the previous catch-all nature of FF that prevented this. Given all that’s come out, particularly about their favours for groups like bankers and builders, it’s not surprising that FF might lose a lot of that support in the medium or long term to Labour.

  2. 14 June, 2010 at 8:32 pm

    What do you make of Bruton? Fascinating times….

    • William
      16 June, 2010 at 2:14 pm

      I can relate more to Bruton, and I think most people can, they feel more confident that he knows what he’s talking about when it comes to the economy, which is what most people worry about now. At the same time, I can sympathize with Sarah Carey’s piece today, that Bruton can lack charisma too at times. Sadly, that seems to be just something in our character as Blueshirts.

  3. 15 June, 2010 at 11:35 am

    I think the reaction of Bruton has highlighted that FG don’t believe Labour’s popularity is a blip. The current leadership debacle is both fascinating and mournful. As a sports fan, it’s fun to watch but as a citizen, I wish they realized the power they have.

    • William
      16 June, 2010 at 2:21 pm

      Especially now that a strong opposition is so important. Unless there’s a decisive result on Thursday, things can only get worse for the party, both in terms of opinion polls and increasing internal divisions, something I would not look forward to.

  1. No trackbacks yet.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: